And chemoprevention of colon cancer: an interview with Dr. John Letterio, School of Medicine of Case Western Reserve University -
Interview by April Cashin -Garbutt , BA Hons (Cantab)
How is defined chemoprevention?
The basic idea of cancer chemoprevention is to stop or reverse the progression of premalignant cells to full malignancy, using physiological mechanisms that do not kill healthy cells.
approach involves using either pharmacological or natural agents that inhibit the development of invasive cancer, either by blocking the DNA damage that initiates the carcinogenesis or by stopping or reversing the progression of precancerous cells in where such damage has already occurred.
ideal chemoprevention agent will be safe, orally bioavailable and well tolerated, so that it can be acceptable for routine use as an approach to reduce the risk of cancer an individual .
The term "chemoprevention" was invented back nearly four decades. How much progress has been made since then?
Michael Sporn coined the term in an article chemoprevention 1976 Federation Proceedings when writing about the work of his group was done with vitamin A analogues
Dr. Sporn, then a member of Carcinogenesis Program at the National cancer Institute, led the first work with agents that might be used to prevent cancer.
Since then, there has been tremendous progress in the field of preclinical research where many studies by leading researchers in the field have demonstrated the utility of this approach in animals experimental.
Indeed, in these preclinical models, it is now possible to prevent the onset of cancer in almost all public bodies in which human carcinoma occurs. However, this success has not been limited to human disease models as chemoprevention has been validated in people.
For example, the use of selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs), granted as much as a five fold reduction in breast cancer incidence in estrogen receptor-positive women
These compounds -. including tamoxifen, raloxifene and lasofoxifene - have the advantage of eliminating osteoporosis. Fenretinide, for which we have data value of nearly 20 years, provides a significant prevention of breast cancer in premenopausal women.
Yet despite these successes, the general acceptance of chemoprevention still an obstacle that must be overcome and it is. real concern that the concept is not only misunderstood by the general public, but not yet fully embraced by the cancer community
Could you please brief introduction to the class of molecules you worked - synthetic triterpenoids?
triterpenoids are a class of biologically active plant metabolites biosynthesized six isoprene units and cyclized in a variety of skeletal scaffolds.
The acid natural triterpenoid oleanolic has been shown to be an effective platform for synthetic derivatization to generate chemoprevention agents that target the antioxidant and factor erythroid 2-factor (NF-E2) concerning nuclear PI 2 (Nrf2) transcriptional cytoprotective path between other pathways involved in inflammation and cancer.
Indeed, the synthetic triterpenoid used in our recently published in JCI study was derived from oleanolic acid. This natural triterpene is representative of a broad class of molecules ubiquitously present in the plant kingdom, with many widely used in Asian medicine and continually isolated and studied for anti-inflammatory, hepatoprotective, analgesic, antimicrobial, immunomodulatory and effects tonics.
Because many plants containing triterpenoids are readily eaten by wild animals and humans, it could be expected that the content of the plant are relatively nontoxic and could serve as platforms as safe for drug discovery.
In preclinical studies, these triterpenoids have also been shown to be neuroprotective. Our own data showed the ability of synthetic triterpenoids selected to completely reverse the clinical signs of neurodegeneration in mouse models of multiple sclerosis. (Http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3242013/?tool=pubmed)
It was announced recently that these molecules carry enormous potential to remove colon cancer associated colitis. Why do patients with inflammatory bowel disease have a higher risk of colon cancer?
It is well established that people with Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis (the most common forms of IBD) are at a higher risk of developing colorectal cancer (CRC) that the population General. Actually, IBD with colon involvement is among the first three conditions at high risk for CRC, which represents nearly 15% of deaths in patients with IBD.
The link between inflammation and cancer is well established and inflammation undoubtedly contributes to other forms of sporadic and hereditary forms of colon cancer.
A number of very elegant studies in preclinical models have shed enormous light on the mechanisms involved. The picture that emerges is that there are distinct roles for specific immune cells, cytokines and other soluble mediators in the initiation, promotion, progression and metastasis of colon cancer.
A proposed mechanism is that the chronic inflammation of the intestine leads to colorectal dysplasia and the optionally colorectal cancer. Chronic inflammation is characterized by the production of proinflammatory cytokines that can induce mutations in oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes (eg., p53, APC ) and genomic instability through various mechanisms.
Chronic inflammation can act favoring CAC activating proliferation and anti-apoptotic (pro-survival) properties precancerous cells, and also enhance their potential for tumor progression and metastasis by influencing the microenvironment in which they grow.
This effect, in part, is related to the ability of inflammatory cytokines as mediators to activate STAT3 and NFkB, which are important in many inflammatory pathways, but also closely involved in the regulation of tumorigenesis.
The critical point is that all these mediators can be modulated in strategies to halt the progression of the disease. CRC is highly treatable at an early stage, it is important not only to understand the risk, but also recognize the signs and symptoms -. And why regular screenings and early detection are essential
However, the potential that we can further reduce the risk through the application of chemopreventive strategies that target these inflammatory mediators is very real and must be exploited to the clinical benefit.
How are synthetic triterpenoids thought to help protect against colon cancer?
When examining the mechanisms of activity for this class of small molecules it is very important to know and understand their nature "multi-functional", ie, their ability to influence several targets within a cell. Indeed, it is this property that may underlie their unique potential as chemopreventive
For example, triterpenoids directly inhibit the function of both STAT3 and NF? B, key intermediates in colon tumorigenesis process .
Dr. Sporn began synthesis triterpenoids in 1995, shortly after leaving the NCI for Dartmouth. Since then, Dr. Sporn was a collaborator on more than 100 publications have described the mediation mechanisms of several synthetic triterpenoids activities and have demonstrated their effectiveness in cancer chemoprevention in numerous preclinical models of epithelial cancers.
When I entered Case Western Reserve University in 06, I began to interact with Dr. Markowitz, who described 15-PGDH as a suppressor large tumor in colon cancer and as a related molecule to "celecoxib nature."
We were intrigued by the finding that inflammatory cytokines, such as TNF-α, could suppress the expression of 15-PGDH and wondered if the triterpenoids may reverse this suppression.
it proved to be true, showing potentially important mechanisms by which this class of small molecules can suppress colon cancer associated colitis, and may improve the response to COX-2 inhibitors.
What are the next steps in your research?
Our current studies focus on the analysis of this triterpenoid (CDDO-Me / bardoxolone methyl) in other models of IBD and in additional models of colon cancer, and the new data these studies are corroborating the results reported in JCI.
We are also very interested in the potential that natural triterpenoids with similar properties could provide a similar benefit. Our efforts in this regard involves both the isolation of the natural product and similar characterization in vitro analyzes and through in vivo Studies of cancer chemoprevention.
As our data with these mature Triterpenes natural, we expect these collective observations will pave the way for human trials in which cancer chemoprevention by triterpenoids may be achieved in patients who are at risk significantly high.
This may be particularly beneficial in patients with IBD, multiple mechanisms of triterpenoid activity (eg suppression of NFkB and STAT3 signaling, induction of TGF signaling -β, activation of antioxidant Nrf2 response), all can work together to achieve improvements in most clinical IBD.
are there plans to continue human trials in cancer chemoprevention with triterpenoids?
The synthetic triterpenoids, including CDDO-Me (bardoxolone methyl) and an analog bound (RTA 408) are currently being studied in clinical development in a wide range of indications by our collaborator Reata Pharmaceuticals.
Notably, Reata is assessing the immuno-oncology RTA 408 applications in the first clinical trials in melanoma and cancer non-small cell lung, and we expect that positive clinical data histologies interest will be expanded in the future.
In addition to this program, we also have an active effort focused on isolating and unique derivatization, natural triterpenoids.
this initiative involves university-industry collaboration has recently established between Case Western Reserve University (CWRU) and Modularix, by which individual candidate molecules and developed CWRU are selected for their potential as immune modulators and their ability to suppress cancer metastasis.
what do you think the future chemoprevention of colon cancer?
The argument for the continuation of these cancer chemoprevention trials is strong, and has been elegantly defended by Dr. Sporn for many decades.
we could say that we have an obligation to patients suffering from diseases such as IBD and other conditions that increase the risk of cancer :. the obligation to develop these safe and multi-functional agents as an approach to minimize their risk of many diseases of clinical manifestations, including cancer
There are many questions that remain unanswered:
- triterpenoid what will be the safest and most effective in this context
- may benefit clinically be achieved with intermittent exposure, rather? by continuous administration? This will likely be one approach to reduce the risk of complications.
- these triterpenoids may be used in combination with other agents for clinical benefit more?
clinical trials designed with care and a collaborative approach between industry and academia are needed to answer these questions, but there is no doubt that the data led us to where we really have an obligation to do so.
where readers find more information?
- http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v471/n7339_supp/full/471S10a.html
- http://www.nature.com / nrclinonc / newspaper / v2 / n10 / full / ncponc0319.html
- http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20420949
About Dr. John Letterio
John Letterio is the director of the Institute of cancer Angie Fowler Adolescent & Young adult hematology and head / pediatric oncology in University hospitals Case Medical Center and Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio. Dr. Letterio obtained his Ohio University's medical school State University of Medicine in 1984 completed a pediatric oncology fellowship at the National Cancer Institute in Bethesda, Maryland in 1993. NIH, Dr. Letterio became a permanent researcher and head of the Laboratory of Immune.
After 16 years at NIH, he was recruited at the Case Western Reserve University in 06 to lead the development of programs for children, adolescents and young adults with cancer to blood disorders. As a member of the case Comprehensive Cancer Center and president Jane & Lee Pediatric Cancer Innovation, he leads a core team of scientists and clinical investigators whose efforts are focused on the development and application of new agents for the chemoprevention and cancer treatment.
His research is actively supported by several NIH institutes, including the NCI, NHLBI and NIS, and the Ministry of Defence. His research team has provided important information about the mechanisms linking inflammation to cancer and other diseases. Her most recent studies have demonstrated the potential of synthetic triterpenoids in chemoprevention of colon cancer and appear in the Journal of Clinical Investigation in June 2014.